Thursday, May 15, 2008

CSRF Protection

As of this posting CSRF (Cross Site Request Forgery) stands as fifth top most threat for web applications. For information on what CSRF is, read on

1. A good protection against this attack is to re-authenticate (like transaction password) or better use two-factor authentication for critical transactions like fund transfer. Taking the CSRF vulnerability from Hacme Casino a good solution would be ask for transaction password as shown in the screenshot below -

2. Another solution is to implement one time nonces. For more information refer the link mentioned above.

3. ASP.Net
Myth: Having ViewState enabled in a .Net web app would prevent against CSRF attacks.

Fact: Having ViewStateUserKey set and set to something that is distinct to each user like "ViewStateUserKey = Session.SessionID" will save you against CSRF attacks.

Saturday, May 3, 2008

Gmail Session Hijacking in 7steps

Session tokens are crown jewels of user identity on a web application. It's no hidden fact that attacks such as XSS (Cross Site Scripting) are on all time rise that steal these tokens leading to user identity theft.

Although adequate community emphasis has been laid on XSS & its countermeasures, there are other prevalent techniques and wide-spread issues that can steal session tokens perhaps more easily.

The one that I share here is network eavesdropping/sniffing.

A vast majority of the web applications that I have come across use HTTP, post authentication. Example: Gmail, Yahoo, Orkut or for that matter any popular public portal. The list includes several intranet/online financial and payroll apps we see day in and day out.

Below we see a step-by-step attack where we steal session ID of a Gmail user and hijack it in the process. (The credit for this exercise is shared with my colleague, Raj,

1. The screenshot below simulates a victim ( who is currently accessing his/her Gmail account over a corporate LAN, Cyber Cafe' or Wi-fi hotspot. As we see in the URL bar, the communication is happening over HTTP, i.e. plain text.

2. The second screenshot simulates an attacker sitting somewhere in the same LAN. Though the LAN is a switched environment, the attacker has used a tool called Cain & Abel to become man-in-the-middle (MITM) (there are many tools that can be used to set this up. Ettercap is a good example. We use Cain & Abel for our long time friendship with the tool. We have used it to sniff passwords travelling on SMTP and POP on numerous occasions).

The blue circle in the screenshot (IP: highlights the Internet gateway address that we ARP spoof for victim (IP:, highlighted in red circle. The second red circle below confirms the success of first step of attack where all victim traffic is getting routed from attacker's machine. By now we should be able to see all traffic going from victim machine.

Let's fire up wireshark to read the victim data (again, you can use any sniffing tools for this) The above screenshot shows wireshark getting started.

3. As shown in the next screenshot we steal victim's gmail cookie details. This is highlighted in the red circle (IP:

4. We copy the cookie details and paste it on a notepad as shown below

Gmail uses GX token from cookie to track users. It's highlighted in the screenshot above. We just need this value to hijack victim's account.

5. As shown in the screenshot below, we go back to attacker's login ( and use a firefox add-on called Cookie Editor to insert the stolen cookie.

6. We now paste the stolen GX value in the cookie editor as shown below. (We did some trial and error and removed many other cookies. We also changed token value for

7. Alright. We are done. Now change the URL in the attacker's browser to the one highlighted in the screenshot below (some other gmail links were logging us out directly. This one didn't. There might be others too that could give you the access similarly. It's all trial and error). Gmail shows you logged on as victim !!!
(highlighted in second red circle)

Now that we have seen how simple this attack can be (Wi-fi would be even easier. No ARP spoofing required. It's all broadcast. On top of that many still use WEP. WEP is trivial to crack) and the associated threats, let's look at the countermeasures.


1. Use HTTPS
CAVEAT: On a switched LAN, MITM is still possible but your browser will warn you. It will show a certificate error. Users need to take this error seriously and alert the support/security staff. Gmail provides optional email access over but it is insufficient as it makes other requests over HTTP. Nevertheless you will get a browser warning as soon as the MITM happens (certificate error). You can act upon it accordingly. Yahoo & majority of the other public portals do not provide options HTTPS access.

2. If HTTPS is not possible for performance reasons, use multiple cookies & continuous (page-wise or request-wise) tracking mechanism that detects a sudden new connection & logs out the user automatically.
CAVEAT: This might still be breakable by an attacker if the MITM started before victim's first access to the site.